What was your exposure to animals growing up?
Submitted by art on Fri, 2008-09-26 10:37.
Were you around pets or farm animals growing up? Or maybe you were raised in a zoo like Art (on Monkey Island)? There are some theories that suggest exposure to animals in childhood can impact the development of your immune system.
I have MS and had frequent exposure
69% (227 votes)
I have MS and had infrequent exposure
24% (80 votes)
I don't have MS and had frequent exposure
4% (14 votes)
I don't have MS and had infrequent exposure
2% (7 votes)
Total votes: 328


I was brought up on a
I was brought up on a poultry farm - we five children played with the birds like most children play with dolls and teddys - and, to possibly make things worse, I had a parrot who was on my shoulder unless I was actually in school. Toby (the parrot) loved to nibble my teeth - wonder what the health & safty boffins would make of that. Come to that, even I'm beginning to wonder - I thought it was good to expose children to 'a peck of dirt' but perhaps I had rather more than my peck!
As a child I had summer
As a child I had summer exposure to grandparents dairy farm... calves, cattle, dogs, cats, chickens...
As an adult, I had exposure to horses, dogs, cats in the interval before my first symptoms.
1 cat 2 dogs But, I think
1 cat
2 dogs
But, I think that I have had MS for most of my life, being - Colic as a baby (still have problems), bladder problems started at 12 and is worsening, bowel problems since birth, etc...
I wonder how many MS's patients have had symptoms all their lives, or was it just a 'sudden' exacerbation?
Kathy Kay
Kathy: I believe I have had
Kathy:
I believe I have had MS symptons most of my life and just realized it last year when gathering all my health information for a trial at the Shepherd MS Center in Atlanta, GA. I was born July 1958 (Do not know if I had colic) but do know that my immune system has never been very good and I have always had bowel and some bladder problems. I would get a rash every Spring and Fall kinda like poisin Ivy but the doctor always said it was allergy related but I can document MS type symptoms as early as 6, 8, 11, 13, 20, 23.......diagnosed RRMS Aug 1999 then April 2001 SPMS but now Neuro says RRMS Jan 2008. My symptoms are eye problems, spasms, face pain, seizures, pins and needles, numbness, banding around stomach, bowel problems, off balance or extremely clumsy, some bladder, tremor down spine, headaches or migraines...etc. It sounds like alot but TO ME the body is amazing what hurts one day is still there but the pain is not as bad. Now some days about 1 week of the month it is!!
However I feel extremely fortunate that I am able to walk and live a full life very happily most of the time. I am blessed with an awesome loving husband of 31 years, 2 children with 2 spouses that I could not have picked better and best of all 3 and 1 one on the way grandbabies who call me ZANY thanks to my son in law that I met for the 1st time when I had one of my exacerbations and the 1st 3 day absence/clonic seizure.
I have 1 dog but have been around lots of animals of all different kinds my entire life. Also love spending time outdoors in the woods, rivers, ocean, mountains and grew up camping, water sports and outdoors.
We may HAVE MS but MS Does not HAVE US! We still have choices and Life and most importantly Love which I find to be a tremendous Wealth!
Patricia Cooke Smith As a
Patricia Cooke Smith
As a young child I spent time on my Uncle's farm on the James River 60 miles east of Richmond, Virginia. My Uncle raised hogs, butchered the hogs and cured the hams on the property just next to the house, well and outhouse. We all drank well water and used that same outhouse.
I have always wondered if that set of living conditions fostered MS that two of the cousins I slept with along with my Uncle and my Father all had or have...one of the female cousins is still alive and in a nursing home in Virginia...
I did not grow up with animals but have always had pets once I moved out on my own...right now I have a 12 year old maltese and a 6 month old maltese that make it so I have to get up and feed them even if I feel lazy. I uploaded a photo of my two dogs...don't know how to get it on the air butI am sure Accelerated Cure can try. Pat
I moved to a farm and had
I moved to a farm and had horses, cows, chickens, dogs, and cats. I was recently dxd with Lyme just after being told I was now progressive, and I am getting better. Hmmm someone with progressive MS getting better? I don't think it's the animals themselves we should be worried about, it's what the animals can carry. Ticks for instance.
What led them to test for
What led them to test for Lyme at this stage of the game for you? I was tested for Lyme in the very beginning but feel like I should get tested again. I have struggled with a rash all summer. Now I feel like if I ask for a Lyme test the docs will think I am a hypochondriac. What made the docs test you now after being told you had progressive ms?
Brought up with lots of hogs
Brought up with lots of hogs from birth to aduit. Dx with MS age 39.
No pets ever. Limited
No pets ever. Limited exposure to friends with animals in the home. I'm a people person, not an animal person. I am horribly allergic to most any animal that has hair or fur. I can't even sleep on feather pillows or use down bedding - I end up with eye and sinus infections.
Lived in "town" until I was 11 and then moved to the country. We had ducks, turkeys, chickens (of all varieties), rabbits, cows, pigs, and horses. I did have a pet peacock that lived in the house with us for about two weeks (from hatching until it died). No matter where I have lived, my allergies have gotten progressively worse. My food allergies make it nearly impossible to eat!
Like others, I too can think back over twenty years (I'm 37) and can say that I probably had signs of MS that long ago. I was diagnosed in August 2005 moving quickly from RRMS to Progressive, now retired.
Grew up in the city, but
Grew up in the city, but always had pets in the house. Mostly dogs and canaries, but as I got older and able to care for pets, I had mice, stray cats, hamsters and parakeets. Once we had kids we their "pets" too including garter snakes, goldfish, turtles, one lonely crawfish and cockatiels. All creatures were under my loving care (cleaning cages, feeding, etc.) before I was diagnosed at age 46. I agree with Kathy and Sharon about having MS or some precursor for all my life. Not sure about the colic, but skin rashes galore, bouts of clumsiness, and occasional GI track problems. Anybody out there make a habit of eating stuff right from the garden without washing it as a kid? How about dead, dried up worms? Yech! I'm told that as a toddler, I would routinely pick them off the sidewalk and pop them into my mouth! Can I blame my MS on those worms?
Most of the theories on pets
Most of the theories on pets involve the idea that having been exposed would be protective for a disease like MS. Eating worms was probably good for you!
***
Art Mellor, Accelerated Cure Project for MS, art-msnews -at- acceleratedcure.com
Based on the responses thus
Based on the responses thus far, and if exposure is thought to be protective for MS, there are a lot of us out there who weren't exposed to the "right" animals. Even dead worms didn't protect me. Maybe they'll have to rethink that exposure theory.
I was diagnosed with MS in
I was diagnosed with MS in August 2007 at age 42, after losing my sight in my left eye, with no apparent cause according to my eye doctor. She sent me to my GP, who sent me to the nuerologist, who sent me for the tests that made the diagnosis. My sight returned on it's own just as randomly as it had vanished.
I was around animals of all types since birth. We lived on a farm, dairy and vegetables. We always had animals in the house and in the yard. Whatever I could feed and pet was always a friend. I was a barefoot country child so I walked in everything imaginable! If MS can come from the animals, I was definately on the front lines. I still have cats, dogs, rabbits and fish. Wild chickens frequent my yard, as do birds of every kind since I always keep out food.
I think I've had MS since at least high school. Over the years I've always had strange symptoms, things that lasted for a few days to a few weeks. Usually by the time I would finally think about going to the doctor, they went away on their own. I normally just attributed everything to stress. I got married, my husband was laid off from work. We had our daughter, then moved around a lot. We got divorced. I became a single mom. I went to college, worked full time, did the girl scout stuff, and raised my daughter through her teenage years! She's 19 and in college now!
With my daughter, we went through the usual cycle of hamsters, mice, gerbals and a few birds. She had a few turtles and lizards as well and like most moms, I was the one who ultimately ended up caring for everything.
I look back and see that all of the random symptoms I'd been having were likely early MS symptoms that went undiagnosed.
Always had cats & dogs @
Always had cats & dogs @ home, spent time with horses in summers growing up. Diagnosed in 1979 w/ RRMS. Still okay, despite major relapse this year (May - just feeling better now ...
Always had dogs ............
Always had dogs ............ wonder about exposure to the distemper vaccine. I know I have heard of an outbreak of ms in regard to dogs with distemper. I actually had a dog as a child that contracted distemper; my father refused to put him down and nursed him back to health somehow. I have a sister with ms as well. I have learend that the distemper vaccine is a modified live vaccine. My last bad attack came after my dogs were vaccinated for distemper.
I remembering hearing a few
I remembering hearing a few years back that there was a theory of some sort of connection between canine distemper and MS. Growing up my family had a dog that had to be put down because he had canine distemper. I mentioned this to my neurologist and he asked me - how many of your siblings have MS (I have 6 siblings), to which I had to respond, none, just me.
My family usually had some sort of pet from the time I was about 6 or 7. Dogs, fish, "disposable turtles" (remember those little green ones that died after about a week and are now not sold anywhere because of salmonella concerns); a chicken (a chick from an elementary school egg hatching 'experiment'); a rabbit.
I was diagnosed at age 36, but I'm fairly certain I'd already had it at least four years at that point in time.
AND a rescue dog we took in
AND a rescue dog we took in was ill and died soon after
I find that nowadays frequently a cat scratch leaves me requiring penicillin, as I begin to get ill soon afterwards
Otherwise, we had cats and dogs over the years.
One sister loved animals and managed to bring in ALL kinds, including reptiles. I wasn't interested in any but the cats and dogs, so only handled them.
I had many stray cats. I
I had many stray cats. I had to get rabbie shots after a kitten bite me and then ran away. I also had dogs- both inside and out. Baby chicks in the house till they started flying around and made my mom cry.
There were pets in my house
There were pets in my house before I was born. There has never been a time in my life when I didn't have a pet. I always petted and/or held any animal I could. I was never afraid of any animal of any kind. My mom and I can remember incidents from my childhood that could have been MS symptoms but they always lasted only a brief time so we were never too overly concerned.My entire life I have had a weakened immune system. I always blamed this on my father smoking. I have read in medical literature lots of times that smoking causes a weakened immune system as well as not being exposed to germs. I have never read anything about exposure to pets contributing to this problem. Makes no difference--I will not live without my pets. They bring too much joy into my life.
I strongly support what's
I strongly support what's being said about having had ms decades before it was finally diagnosed. I'm not so sure about doctors not suspecting what was wrong with me but being wary of telling me when the remission phase was still fairly short.
I've been around cats and dogs most of my life and I'm not prone to allergies. I've always attributed this to my exposure to pets from infancy. I do react very strongly to mosquito and gnats' bites though. I've also had thyroid trouble since pregnancy and have been operated twice in my life. I wonder if any studies are concerned with this aspect, especially since some of the symptoms I had before my second operation were fairly similar to my ms symptoms.
Please take me off the
Please take me off the animal format. I have voted and would like to call an end to it all. It would be nice to blame it on my old dead dogs--but I will not do it.
We always had a dog and a
We always had a dog and a cat. Usually, multiple dogs. I still have two dogs and two cats at the age of 47. I don't know about my immuned system, buy I know my mental health is enhanced by their unconditional love. Whether I'm having a good day out in the yard or a bad day curled up on the couch. They always check on me and keep me going. I love them and they give it back with out question. They don't hold a grudge and the don't scold me for not writing down something I know I will forget. They gave me the same security when I was a child dealing with my life as it was laid out. I hope there is no negative findings about animal exposure. I don't know what I would have done with the exposure I was lucky enough to experience. Thanks, Lisa